Dimensions Explained: The Four We Know and the Extra Ones Physics Proposes

Dimensions Explained: The Four We Know and the Extra Ones Physics Proposes

To tell a friend where to meet you in a tall building, you need three numbers: how far along the street, how far back from it and which floor. To make sure you actually meet, you need a fourth: the time. That is what "dimension" means in physics. It is the number of separate measurements needed to pin down where something is. Everyday life needs three for space and one for time. Some theories of physics say there are more, hidden from view. Here is what is known, what is proposed and how the two differ.

A line, a square, a cube and a glowing four-dimensional cube floating in a row in space

Illustration: from one dimension to four.

Zero to three: the dimensions of space

  1. A point (zero dimensions) is a position with no size. Euclid's Elements, written around 300 BCE, opens with the definition "a point is that which has no part".
  2. A line (one dimension) needs one number to say where you are on it, like a bead on a wire.
  3. A surface (two dimensions) needs two, like latitude and longitude on a map. In 1637 René Descartes published the idea of locating points with numbers along axes, which turned geometry into algebra. The x–y graph is named "Cartesian" after him.
  4. Space (three dimensions) needs three: left–right, forward–back and up–down. Mathematicians extended Descartes' method to three axes in the following century.

Mathematicians soon saw that nothing stops the method at three. In 1854 Bernhard Riemann gave a lecture on geometry in any number of dimensions, including curved ones. Later in the century, writers tried to help people picture a fourth spatial dimension. Edwin Abbott's 1884 novella Flatland is narrated by a square living in a two-dimensional world. He cannot imagine "up" until a sphere passes through his plane and appears to him as a circle that grows and shrinks. Charles Hinton coined the word "tesseract" in 1888 for the four-dimensional version of a cube.

Time as the fourth dimension

In 1905 Einstein's special relativity showed that measurements of space and time depend on how fast you are moving. Two observers moving relative to each other disagree about lengths and durations, but they agree on a particular combination of the two. In 1908 Einstein's former teacher Hermann Minkowski turned this into geometry. He treated space and time as a single four-dimensional "spacetime" and told his audience, "Henceforth space by itself, and time by itself, are doomed to fade away into mere shadows."

This has practical consequences. Clocks on GPS satellites tick faster than clocks on the ground by about 38 millionths of a second a day, because of their speed and weaker gravity. Without relativity corrections, GPS positions would drift by several kilometres a day.

Extra dimensions: an idea from 1919

In 1919 Theodor Kaluza, a German mathematician, wrote to Einstein with an idea. If he rewrote Einstein's gravity in five dimensions instead of four, the equations for electromagnetism appeared automatically. Einstein was impressed, and the paper was published in 1921. The obvious objection was that nobody sees a fifth direction. In 1926 Oskar Klein suggested an answer. The extra dimension could be curled into a tiny circle, far smaller than an atom, so small that nothing we can see or measure would notice it.

The usual way to picture this is a tightrope. To a tightrope walker, the rope is a line with one direction: forwards or back. To an ant on the rope, there is a second direction, around the rope. That direction is curled up and small, so only something small can use it. Extra dimensions in physics are meant to work the same way, only far smaller.

String theory and M-theory

String theory, developed from the late 1960s, proposes that the basic building blocks of nature are tiny vibrating strings rather than points. Different vibrations would appear to us as different particles. The theory works mathematically only in ten dimensions: nine of space and one of time. In 1984 Michael Green and John Schwarz showed that a version of it avoided a fatal mathematical inconsistency, and interest in it surged. In 1995 Edward Witten showed that the five competing versions of string theory looked like different limits of a single theory in eleven dimensions, now called M-theory (Witten, 1995).

In these theories the six or seven extra space dimensions are curled into complicated tiny shapes. The best-known family is called Calabi–Yau spaces. The exact shape would decide which particles and forces exist.

One common misunderstanding needs clearing up. Many popular videos and articles give each extra dimension a meaning: the fifth is "other possible futures", the sixth "parallel worlds", and so on. Physics doesn't number or describe them that way. In string theory the extra dimensions are all of the same kind: extra directions of space, curled up small. The "ladder of dimensions" with a different idea on each step is a modern invention, not physics.

Could extra dimensions explain why gravity is weak?

Gravity is extraordinarily weak compared with the other forces. A small fridge magnet holds itself up against the pull of the entire Earth. In 1998 Nima Arkani-Hamed, Savas Dimopoulos and Gia Dvali proposed that gravity might seem weak because it spreads into extra dimensions that are larger than usually assumed, possibly up to a millimetre across (Arkani-Hamed, Dimopoulos and Dvali, 1998). The other forces and particles would be confined to our familiar three. In 1999 Lisa Randall and Raman Sundrum proposed a related idea with a single, warped extra dimension.

These proposals made testable predictions, and so far the tests have come back empty:

  1. Tabletop experiments. If gravity leaked into millimetre-sized dimensions, it would get stronger at very short distances. Researchers at the University of Washington used a sensitive torsion balance and found that ordinary gravity holds down to 52 micrometres, thinner than a human hair (Lee and colleagues, 2020).
  2. The Large Hadron Collider. Some versions predicted that collisions at CERN would create tiny short-lived black holes or particles carrying energy into extra dimensions. Searches since 2010 have found neither.

Where things stand

Three dimensions of space and one of time are established by every measurement ever made. Extra dimensions are a serious mathematical idea that runs through some of the most ambitious theories in physics, but no experiment has detected them, and string theory itself has not yet made a prediction that has been confirmed. They may be too small ever to observe directly, or they may not exist.

So the honest answer to "how many dimensions are there?" is "at least four, and possibly more". Nobody knows, and physicists are still testing it. For more on how numbers and patterns get stretched beyond the evidence, see the mystery of 3, 6 and 9.

Sources

  1. Project Gutenberg, "Flatland: A Romance of Many Dimensions by Edwin Abbott Abbott". https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/201
  2. arXiv, "[hep-th/9503124] String Theory Dynamics In Various Dimensions". https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9503124
  3. Arkani–Hamed N, Dimopoulos S, Dvali G, "The hierarchy problem and new dimensions at a millimeter", Physics Letters B 429 (1998): 263-272. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0370-2693(98)00466-3
  4. Lee J, Adelberger E, Cook T, Fleischer S et al. (2020). New Test of the Gravitational 1 / r 2 Law at Separations down to 52     μ m . Physical Review Letters 124:. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.124.101101

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.

Log in to post a comment.