Who Discovered Black Holes? From Michell's 'Dark Stars' to the First Image

Who Discovered Black Holes? From Michell's 'Dark Stars' to the First Image

Black holes are often credited to Einstein, but he didn't predict them and for years he argued they couldn't exist. The idea is older than his theory of gravity, its mathematics came from someone else, and astronomers didn't find one until the 1970s. The full answer to "who discovered black holes?" runs through about a dozen people over more than two centuries.

A black hole with a glowing orange disk bending starlight around it

Illustration: a black hole bending light around it.

1783: John Michell's "dark stars"

John Michell was a clergyman in Yorkshire and one of the best scientific minds in England. In 1783 he sent a paper to the Royal Society. He reasoned with Newton's gravity and assumed, as Newton did, that light is made of tiny particles. A star of the Sun's density but about 500 times its width would then have an escape velocity faster than light, and its light could never leave. Such a star would be invisible. Michell went further. He suggested we might still detect one if a visible star were orbiting it, by watching how the visible star moved (Michell, Philosophical Transactions, 1784). That is very close to how the first black hole was actually found, nearly 200 years later.

The French mathematician Pierre-Simon Laplace reached the same idea independently in 1796, but dropped it from later editions of his book. Once experiments in the early 1800s showed light behaving as a wave, the "dark star" idea faded.

1915–16: Schwarzschild solves Einstein's equations

In November 1915 Einstein completed general relativity, which describes gravity as the curving of space and time by mass and energy. The equations were so complicated that Einstein expected exact solutions to be out of reach. Within weeks Karl Schwarzschild found one. He was a German astronomer serving as an artillery officer on the Russian front. His solution describes the curved spacetime around a single, non-rotating ball of mass. He sent it to Einstein, who presented it to the Prussian Academy in January 1916 (English translation).

The solution contains a critical radius, now called the Schwarzschild radius. If a mass is squeezed inside it, nothing can get out. For the Sun that radius is about 3 km, and for the Earth about 9 mm. Schwarzschild didn't think any real object could be that compact. He died in May 1916 of an autoimmune skin disease that developed while he was at the front, a few months after his discovery.

Einstein's doubts

For decades most physicists, Einstein included, treated the Schwarzschild radius as a mathematical oddity. In 1939 Einstein published a paper arguing that real matter could never be packed tightly enough to form one (Einstein, Annals of Mathematics, 1939). He was wrong. His argument looked only at matter held in stable orbits, not at a star collapsing under its own weight.

1930s: dying stars that can't stop collapsing

In 1930, on a ship from India to England, 19-year-old Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar calculated that a burnt-out star could not support itself as a white dwarf above a certain mass, now put at about 1.4 Suns (Chandrasekhar, 1931). Arthur Eddington, the most famous astronomer in Britain, ridiculed the result at a meeting of the Royal Astronomical Society in 1935. Chandrasekhar was right, and he won the Nobel Prize in 1983.

In 1939 J. Robert Oppenheimer and his student Hartland Snyder followed a collapsing star using general relativity. They showed that a heavy enough star would keep shrinking until it was cut off from the rest of the universe (Oppenheimer and Snyder, 1939). Their paper appeared on 1 September 1939, the day the Second World War began, and it attracted little attention for twenty years.

1958–1967: theory catches up, and a name

A revival came in the late 1950s and 1960s. In 1958 David Finkelstein showed that the Schwarzschild radius is a one-way surface, the event horizon: things can fall in, but nothing comes out. In 1963 Roy Kerr found the solution for a spinning black hole, which is the kind that exists in nature. In 1965 Roger Penrose proved that once collapse passes a certain point, a singularity is unavoidable, even when a star isn't perfectly round. He shared the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics for that work (Nobel Prize press release).

The name arrived around the same time. The journalist Ann Ewing used "black holes" in a 1964 report from a science meeting. The physicist John Wheeler made it famous after using it in a 1967 lecture, and it replaced clumsier terms such as "completely gravitationally collapsed object".

1972: the first one found

Cygnus X-1, discovered in 1964, is one of the brightest X-ray sources in the sky. In 1971–72 two teams independently identified a giant blue star orbiting an invisible companion there. One was Louise Webster and Paul Murdin in Britain, the other Tom Bolton in Canada. The star's motion showed the companion was far too heavy to be a white dwarf or neutron star (Webster and Murdin, 1972; Bolton, 1972). This was Michell's method from 1783: find the dark object by watching its visible partner. Cygnus X-1 is generally counted as the first black hole discovered.

Stars orbiting very close to Sagittarius A*, the black hole at the centre of the Milky Way

Star orbits revealed about 4 million solar masses hidden at the centre of our galaxy. Image: ESO / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

Seeing and hearing them

  1. The black hole at the centre of our galaxy. From the 1990s, teams led by Reinhard Genzel and Andrea Ghez tracked stars orbiting an invisible point at the centre of the Milky Way. The orbits showed it holds about 4 million times the Sun's mass. They shared the 2020 Nobel Prize with Penrose.
  2. Gravitational waves. On 14 September 2015 the LIGO detectors recorded ripples in spacetime from two black holes merging about 1.3 billion light years away (LIGO and Virgo, 2016). It was the first direct detection of gravitational waves and of a black-hole pair.
  3. The first image. In April 2019 the Event Horizon Telescope, a network of radio dishes spanning the Earth, released an image of the shadow of the black hole in the galaxy M87, about 6.5 billion times the Sun's mass (EHT Collaboration, 2019). An image of the Milky Way's own black hole followed in 2022.

So who discovered black holes?

For the idea, the credit goes to John Michell in 1783. For the mathematics, Karl Schwarzschild in 1916, building on Einstein's theory. Oppenheimer and Snyder showed in 1939 how stars could form black holes, and Penrose in 1965 showed that collapse makes them unavoidable. The first observational discovery came in 1972, from Webster, Murdin and Bolton studying Cygnus X-1. Einstein supplied the theory that made all of it possible, and spent years doubting the result.

For more on how scientists read the sky, see our posts on the mysteries of the stars and what causes the northern lights.

Sources

  1. , "VII. On the means of discovering the distance, magnitude, &c. of the fixed stars, in consequence of the diminution of the velocity of their light, in case such a diminution should be found to take place in any of them, and such other data should be procured from observations, as would be farther necessary for that purpose. By the Rev. John Michell, B.D. F.R.S. In a letter to Henry Cavendish, Esq. F.R.S. and A.S", Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 74 (1784): 35-57. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstl.1784.0008
  2. arXiv, "[physics/9905030] On the gravitational field of a mass point according to Einstein's theory". https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/9905030
  3. Einstein A, "On a Stationary System With Spherical Symmetry Consisting of Many Gravitating Masses", The Annals of Mathematics 40 (1939): 922. https://doi.org/10.2307/1968902
  4. Chandrasekhar S, "The Maximum Mass of Ideal White Dwarfs", The Astrophysical Journal 74 (1931): 81. https://doi.org/10.1086/143324
  5. Oppenheimer J, Snyder H, "On Continued Gravitational Contraction", Physical Review 56 (1939): 455-459. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.56.455
  6. NobelPrize.org, "Press release: The Nobel Prize in Physics 2020". https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2020/press-release/
  7. WEBSTER B, MURDIN P, "Cygnus X-1: a Spectroscopic Binary with a Heavy Companion ?", Nature 235 (1972): 37-38. https://doi.org/10.1038/235037a0
  8. BOLTON C, "Identification of Cygnus X-1 with HDE 226868", Nature 235 (1972): 271-273. https://doi.org/10.1038/235271b0
  9. Abbott B, Abbott R, Abbott T, Abernathy M et al., "Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger", Physical Review Letters 116 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.116.061102
  10. The Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration, Akiyama K, Alberdi A, Alef W et al., "First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the Supermassive Black Hole", The Astrophysical Journal Letters 875 (2019): L1. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/ab0ec7

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.

Log in to post a comment.