Do Humans Really Belong to Earth? What the 'Aliens' Theory Gets Wrong
In 2013, the American ecologist Ellis Silver published a book arguing that humans did not evolve on Earth at all. He suggested we were brought here from another planet. His evidence was the ways our bodies seem poorly suited to life here: so many of us have bad backs, we burn in the sun, childbirth is unusually dangerous, and chronic disease is widespread. The book was widely shared online. The idea has no scientific support, but the questions it raises are good ones, and the real answers are more interesting than the alien theory.

Illustration: are we made for this planet, or just passing through?
Our DNA says we belong here
Every living thing on Earth uses the same genetic code, with the same three-letter DNA "words" for the same amino acids. Humans share it with bacteria, mushrooms and oak trees. When the chimpanzee genome was sequenced in 2005, single-letter differences from the human genome came to only about 1.2% (Nature, 2005).
Some evidence is like a fingerprint. Great apes have 24 pairs of chromosomes, but humans have 23. Human chromosome 2 carries the remains of two ape chromosomes fused end to end, including leftover chromosome-tip sequences in the middle where the join happened (PNAS, 1991). Our genomes also contain the remains of ancient viral infections, and many sit in exactly the same places in chimpanzee DNA. That only makes sense if we inherited them from a shared ancestor. Fossils from Africa trace the human line back more than six million years.

Walking upright reshaped a spine that evolved in four-legged animals. Photo: Andrew / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
Bad backs: a recent upgrade, not a foreign design
Back pain is real and common. Human ancestors started walking upright only a few million years ago, a short time in evolutionary terms. Our spine, which evolved in four-legged animals, was reshaped into an S-curve to balance an upright body. That works well enough to carry us thousands of kilometres, but it concentrates load on the lower back. The explanation is a recent compromise. A body designed for another planet wouldn't look like this.
Childbirth: big brains and high energy costs
Human babies are born with large heads and are unusually helpless. The classic explanation is the "obstetrical dilemma": walking upright needs a narrow pelvis, while big brains need a wide birth canal. A 2012 study proposed another limit: birth happens when the growing baby's energy needs approach the most a mother's body can sustain. Either way, difficult childbirth is a trade-off from our own evolutionary history.
Sunburn: skin adapted to where our ancestors lived
Skin colour evolved to balance two needs: protection from ultraviolet damage, and making enough vitamin D. Dark skin evolved in equatorial Africa, where sunlight is intense. As people moved to higher latitudes, lighter skin evolved to make vitamin D under weaker sun (Jablonski and Chaplin, 2000). Sunburn is mostly a problem for light-skinned people in strong sun. That is a modern mismatch created by fast travel and migration, not evidence of an alien origin.
Humans are well suited to Earth
For a supposedly fragile species, humans are remarkably good at surviving here. We have millions of sweat glands and very little body hair, which makes us some of the best animals on the planet at shedding heat. Researchers argue that early humans could run down antelope in the midday heat by pursuing them until the prey overheated (Bramble and Lieberman, 2004). We have spread to every continent, from the Arctic to the Sahara, largely by using tools, clothing, fire and cooperation.
The real mismatch
There is a scientific idea behind the sense that we don't quite fit. It is called "evolutionary mismatch". Our bodies evolved for a world of constant physical activity, scarce food, daylight and small social groups. Within a few generations, many people moved to one of sitting, abundant calories, artificial light and screens. Several modern epidemics fit that pattern: short-sightedness in children who spend little time outdoors, obesity, type 2 diabetes and back pain from long hours of sitting.
So the evidence is that humans belong to Earth very thoroughly, down to the chromosome. What we don't always fit is the world we have built on it.
Sources
- The Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium, "Initial sequence of the chimpanzee genome and comparison with the human genome", Nature 437 (2005): 69-87. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature04072
- IJdo J, Baldini A, Ward D, Reeders S et al., "Origin of human chromosome 2: an ancestral telomere-telomere fusion", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 88 (1991): 9051-9055. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.88.20.9051
- Dunsworth H, Warrener A, Deacon T, Ellison P et al., "Metabolic hypothesis for human altriciality", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109 (2012): 15212-15216. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1205282109
- Jablonski N, Chaplin G, "The evolution of human skin coloration", Journal of Human Evolution 39 (2000): 57-106. https://doi.org/10.1006/jhev.2000.0403
- Bramble D, Lieberman D, "Endurance running and the evolution of Homo", Nature 432 (2004): 345-352. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature03052
Comments (0)
Leave a Reply
Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.
Log in to post a comment.