The Constitution of Medina: The Document That Founded a Community

The Constitution of Medina: The Document That Founded a Community

In 622 CE a group of migrants from Mecca arrived in an oasis town about four hundred kilometres to the north. They had no land there and no tribal protection, and no obvious claim on the place that took them in. Soon after their arrival a written agreement was drawn up between them, the local Arab clans, and the Jewish groups attached to those clans. The text survives. It is the oldest document of Islamic political history, and historians have argued about it for more than a century.

In English it is usually called the Constitution of Medina. The Arabic sources call it simply the sahifa, the sheet or the writing. That difference is worth keeping in mind, because much of the modern debate turns on how much the word "constitution" can carry.

The Medina oasis with date palms, wells and fortified farmsteads

Illustration: the oasis of Yathrib (Medina) in the early 7th century.

The town before the document

Yathrib, as Medina was called before the migration, had no government. It was a cluster of fortified hamlets and palm groves held by rival kin groups. The two main Arab tribes, the Aws and the Khazraj, had been feuding for generations. Alongside them lived Jewish groups, some long established, some attached as clients to Arab clans, who owned land and practised crafts and were caught up in the same web of alliances and blood debts as everyone else.

About five years before the migration the feud came to a head at the Battle of Bu'ath, which left both tribes exhausted and neither on top. The sources describe a town that had run out of ways to stop fighting. With every clan its own final court, an arbitrator with standing over all of them had to come from outside. That is the background to the meetings at Aqaba during the pilgrimage seasons, where delegations from Yathrib pledged themselves to Muhammad and invited him to move to their town. He came not as a conqueror but as an outsider with religious authority, a familiar role in Arabian dispute settlement, though the authority he claimed was of a different order.

Where the text comes from

The fullest version is in the biography of the Prophet by Ibn Ishaq (died 767), preserved in the edition of Ibn Hisham (died 833). A second, independent version appears in the Kitab al-Amwal of Abu Ubayd al-Qasim ibn Sallam (died 838), a book on public finance. Later authors such as Ibn Kathir copied it from these.

Two features of that transmission stand out. Ibn Ishaq gives the text without the chain of narrators he normally supplies, presenting it as a document, not as a report, as one would expect of a copy from an archive. And the two independent versions differ in small details but agree on substance, which is what a real text copied twice looks like. Scholars usually number its clauses following the German orientalist Julius Wellhausen, who in 1889 divided it into 47 sections; that numbering is a modern convenience and is not found in the manuscripts.

What it says

The text opens by naming the parties: the believers and Muslims of Quraysh and of Yathrib, and those who follow them and strive alongside them. These, it says, form one umma, distinct from other people. The word has been translated as community, nation and confederation. In this document, whatever exactly it means, it is not simply another word for the Muslims, because the text goes on to include non-Muslims within it. Most of what follows is practical.

Blood money and ransom

Each clan remains responsible, as before, for the blood money owed by its members and for ransoming its own captives. The document does not abolish the tribal system of collective responsibility; it keeps it and binds the clans together at a higher level. The emigrants from Mecca, who had no clan in Yathrib, are treated as a clan of their own for this purpose.

Restraint within the community

The believers are not to leave one of their number weighed down by debt or blood money without help. They are to stand together against any of them who commits a serious wrong, even if he is a close relative. In a society where the first duty was to back one's kin whatever they had done, that was a striking reversal.

Protection

God's protection, the text says, is one, and the humblest member of the community can grant protection that binds all the rest. Where protection was the means of survival, that spread power more widely.

The Jewish groups

The document names a series of Jewish groups attached to particular Arab clans: the Jews of Banu 'Awf, Banu al-Najjar, Banu al-Harith, Banu Sa'ida, Banu Jusham, Banu al-Aws, Banu Tha'laba and others. For each it repeats a formula: they are an umma with the believers; the Jews have their religion and the Muslims theirs; and this applies to their clients and dependants. The obligations run both ways: sharing the costs of war, defending Yathrib together against attack, making no separate peace, and giving no help to the other side's enemies.

Territory and arbitration

The valley of Yathrib is declared sacred and inviolable for the parties. Any dispute that threatens to break the peace is to be referred to God and to Muhammad. The Quraysh of Mecca, and anyone who helps them, are explicitly denied protection.

What historians debate

Almost every scholar who has studied the document accepts that it is early and largely authentic. Wellhausen's argument is still the most cited: the language is archaic, it uses terms that soon dropped out of use, and above all it says things a later forger, with a settled theology and a ninth-century agenda, would have had no reason to invent. It preserves too much of the old tribal machinery to be a later fabrication.

The disagreements are about how it was put together and what it means. The British scholar R. B. Serjeant argued in 1978 that what Ibn Ishaq presents as one text is really several agreements made at different times and later copied together, which would explain its repetitions and abrupt changes of subject. Michael Lecker's detailed study of 2004 also treats it as a composite to be dated clause by clause. The traditional date is soon after the migration, but some clauses seem to assume open war with Mecca, which fits better with the time around the Battle of Badr in 624. If the text is composite, both can be partly right.

An old wall around a farm among date palms in Medina

The document reads more like a treaty between groups that kept their own affairs than a constitution. Photo: Ashashyou / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Then there is the question of which Jews. The three large Jewish tribes best known from the biographies of the Prophet, the Qaynuqa', the Nadir and the Qurayza, are not named in the document. The groups that are named are smaller and appear as clients of Arab clans. Some historians think the large tribes had separate treaties; others that they were covered by a general clause; others that they were never parties at all. The text does not settle it, and the answer affects how the later conflicts with those tribes are understood.

Finally, the word "constitution". The document has no rules on succession, no defined offices, no procedure for making law and no way of amending itself. It looks less like a constitution than a treaty, a hilf in Arabian terms, between groups that kept running their own affairs. What was new was not its form but its reach: it bound together groups with no earlier basis for common obligation, under an arbitrator whose authority came from none of them.

Its place today

Since the twentieth century the document has been cited in arguments about pluralism, citizenship and the place of religious minorities in Muslim-majority states. Those readings have a basis: the text does bind followers of different religions into one order of defence and law, and it does say that each keeps its religion. They are also easy to stretch. The document assumes a world of tribes, not individuals; it shares out obligations between groups, not rights to persons; and its central clauses deal with war, blood money and the exclusion of a particular enemy.

Its historical importance is clearer. In the plain language of a working agreement, it records the moment when a religious community took on a political shape. Each clause solves a practical problem: who pays for a killing, who fights when the oasis is attacked, who decides when two parties cannot agree. In solving them it placed something larger than the tribe at the top of people's loyalties.

Sources

  1. Ibn Ishaq, Sirat Rasul Allah, in the recension of Ibn Hisham, translated by A. Guillaume as The Life of Muhammad (Oxford, 1955), Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/TheLifeOfMohammedGuillaume
  2. R. B. Serjeant, "The Sunnah Jami'ah, pacts with the Yathrib Jews, and the tahrim of Yathrib: analysis and translation of the documents comprised in the so-called 'Constitution of Medina'", Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 41 (1978), reprinted in The Life of Muhammad, ed. Uri Rubin (Routledge, 2022). https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315238678-10
  3. Michael Lecker, The "Constitution of Medina": Muhammad's First Legal Document (Darwin Press, Princeton, 2004).
  4. W. Montgomery Watt, Muhammad at Medina (Oxford, 1956).
  5. Julius Wellhausen, Skizzen und Vorarbeiten, vol. 4 (Berlin, 1889).
  6. "Constitution of Medina", Wikipedia (overview of the text, its transmission and the scholarly debate). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Medina

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.

Log in to post a comment.