Can Humans See Without Eyes? What Echolocation and Brain Scans Show

Can Humans See Without Eyes? What Echolocation and Brain Scans Show

In 1969 the neuroscientist Paul Bach-y-Rita sat blind volunteers in an old dentist's chair fitted with 400 small vibrating pins against their backs. A television camera fed what it saw to the pins, so a shape in front of the camera became a pattern of buzzing on the skin. After some practice, the volunteers could recognise objects and faces and judge where things were in the room. Some later said they stopped noticing the vibrations on their backs. They were aware of the objects out in front of them.

That experiment, published in Nature, raised a question that still drives research: if a blind person can learn to locate a cup through the skin of their back, how much of "seeing" happens in the eyes, and how much in the brain?

A blindfolded person in a dark room surrounded by visible sound waves bouncing off the walls

Illustration: echolocation, one way some blind people 'see' with sound.

Seeing through the tongue and the ears

Bach-y-Rita's chair has shrunk. The BrainPort device puts a small camera on a pair of glasses and turns the image into a grid of gentle electrical pulses on the tongue, which is far more sensitive than the back. In 2015 the US Food and Drug Administration allowed it to be sold as an aid for blind people. In the company's trials, about 69% of the 74 participants could identify an object after a year of training. The FDA described it as a supplement to a cane or guide dog, not a replacement.

Another approach uses sound. A system called The vOICe, developed by the Dutch engineer Peter Meijer from the early 1990s, scans a camera image from left to right and plays it as a sweep of sound. Height is turned into pitch and brightness into loudness. Experienced users describe the result as something closer to vision than to listening.

Clicking to see

Some blind people need no device at all. Daniel Kish, who lost both eyes to cancer as a baby, makes sharp tongue clicks and listens to the echoes. He uses them to hike and to ride a bicycle in traffic. He now teaches the technique to others.

In 2011, researchers in Canada scanned the brains of two expert echolocators while they listened to recordings of their own clicks and echoes. The echoes activated the visual cortex, the part of the brain that normally handles signals from the eyes. Echoes from the left lit up the right side of the visual cortex, just as light from the left would. Sighted volunteers hearing the same recordings showed no such activity. Two people is a very small study, but the result fits a much larger body of research.

Fingertips reading Braille

In people born blind, the visual cortex becomes active when they read Braille. Photo: Eren Li / Pexels

The brain repurposes its visual areas

In 1996 a team at the US National Institutes of Health found that the primary visual cortex becomes active when people who were born blind read Braille with their fingertips. A follow-up in 1997 used magnetic pulses to briefly disrupt that area. Blind readers then made more Braille errors and said the dots felt "flat" or confusing, while sighted people reading raised letters were unaffected. In blind readers, the "visual" brain had become part of the reading system.

This is neural plasticity, the brain's ability to rewire itself, and it is strongest when sight is lost early in life. It also explains why sensory-substitution devices tend to work better with long practice: the brain needs time to build the new connections.

Seeing without knowing it

The strangest case runs the other way: people whose eyes work but who don't experience seeing. After damage to the primary visual cortex, some patients report total blindness in part of their field of view. When pushed to guess where a light is in that blind area, they point at it far more accurately than chance would allow. The British psychologist Lawrence Weiskrantz named this "blindsight" in the 1970s.

In 2008 researchers filmed a man known as TN, who had lost his visual cortex on both sides after two strokes and was considered fully blind. Asked to walk down a corridor without his cane, he stepped around boxes and chairs that had been placed in his way, while insisting he could see nothing. Older routes from the eyes to deeper parts of the brain were still guiding him, below conscious awareness.

Stories and stage acts

Fiction has explored the idea too. Roald Dahl's 1977 short story The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar follows a man who trains for years until he can see without using his eyes. Dahl based it on Kuda Bux, a real stage performer famous for reading and even riding a bicycle through traffic while heavily blindfolded. Blindfold acts like his are generally explained as stagecraft rather than true sight. Ideas about an "inner eye" or "third eye" run through many spiritual traditions, but they belong to belief rather than measurement.

The science points somewhere more modest, and more surprising. The eyes collect light, but seeing is something the brain builds. Given practice and a new stream of information, through the skin, the tongue or the ears, it can build a useful picture of the world without them.

Sources

  1. Thaler L, Arnott S, Goodale M, "Neural Correlates of Natural Human Echolocation in Early and Late Blind Echolocation Experts", PLoS ONE 6 (2011): e20162. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0020162
  2. de Gelder B, Tamietto M, van Boxtel G, Goebel R et al., "Intact navigation skills after bilateral loss of striate cortex", Current Biology 18 (2008): R1128-R1129. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2008.11.002
  3. WEISKRANTZ L, WARRINGTON E, SANDERS M, MARSHALL J, "VISUAL CAPACITY IN THE HEMIANOPIC FIELD FOLLOWING A RESTRICTED OCCIPITAL ABLATION", Brain 97 (1974): 709-728. https://doi.org/10.1093/brain/97.1.709
  • Tags:
  • No tags

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply

Comments are moderated. Please read our Comment Policy before posting.

Log in to post a comment.